John Thomas FIST Platinum Silicone Butt Plug Review

Written by  Jul 11, 2023

If you love a challenge then the Fist will put a smile on your face

I love it when John Thomas Toys (JTT) ask if they can send more of their stunning silicone products to review. I can never say no, even if I am rushed off my feet, as the chance to enjoy another of their great designs is always compelling.

Pulling up my 'big girl panties', I prepared for lots of hard (extremely pleasurable) work. I never have to wait long for the delivery as they are always prompt.

"The feeling of stretch and fullness is fantastic. Instead of moving the Fist in and out of my pussy I enjoy simply twisting it. The sensations of expanding, feeling stretched and full, and the feeling of the Fist turning inside feels terrific. Having it run over my sensitive walls at each spin gives me fantastic sensations."


When they send their toys to me, I generally do not know what treat sits inside the box. So it's always a pleasant surprise when I open the box and get my first look at the contents.

This review is for their Fist butt plug.

Delivery & Packaging

While I get deliveries of review products, I don't want my neighbours to know the kinky stuff I get up to. So discretion is vital. JTT has that covered, as they always use plain, discrete packaging. Even the label does not have the name of the website shown.

Inside the box, everything is packed with plain brown paper to prevent the dildos or butt plugs from moving whilst in transit. Each dildo has minimal packaging, consisting of a robust, clear heat sealed plastic. This plastic helps keep the dildos/butt plugs clean whilst in transit and before they reach their forever home.

Image showing all four sizes of FIST and one storage bag
Image showing all four sizes of FIST and one storage bag.

I like this minimal approach to packaging as it means less waste.

Each Fist has several stickers stuck on the wrapper, one to say the size, one is the JTT logo and one to let you know the firmness rating.

Inside the box, you will also receive a small re-useable plastic carrier bag which contains a JTT branded storage bag. I received four to go with the four plugs. The number and size of the bags will depend on the quantity and size of the butt plug you purchase.

Check Out Our Unboxing Video On Youtube

Check out my unboxing video on Youtube

Materials and design

Fist is made with platinum-grade silicone. This is a more robust but expensive material than some other manufacturers use. It is also my preferred material for insertable toys as it is hypo-allergenic, non-porous, body-safe, PVC, Latex and Phthalate free. It also is an excellent material for temperature play.

JTT uses copper moulds in manufacturing for all their dildos/butt plugs. Whilst this is a more expensive process, it ensures that every item that comes out of that mould will have precisely the same features as the ones before.

This is the best way that JTT can ensure that every Fist purchased will be as it should be. They are so confident of the quality of their wares that they give a lifetime warranty on them, which is fantastic.

Image showing small and medium FIST to highlight the incredible details
Image showing small and medium FIST to highlight the incredible details.

JTT offer a choice of four sizes and two firmness ratings. I was sent the four sizes in the soft rating. For anyone interested in the details, their Soft blend has a shore rating of A-15, and the Medium has a shore rating of A-20.

Fist is a great name; simple, to the point and exactly what it is. Whether new to fisting or not, this is a great option to explore the fantasy of anal fisting.

Its details are amazing; every finger is clearly defined, and they provide some delicious ridges. The raised thumb is fun to insert, but with the additional feel of it stretching you, it feels sublime.

Image showing thumbnail on the FIST butt plug
Image showing thumbnail which is well defined, but don't worry it is very flexible.

One great thing about this design is the four sizing options available. This allows you to start small and gradually buy larger depending on the stretch you are looking for.

Overall Height: 5"/12.7cm 7"/17.78cm 9"/22.86cm 11"/27.94cm
Insertable Length: 4"/10.16cm 5"/12.7cm 7"/17.78cm 9"/22.86cm
Circumference (above knuckle): 6.29"/16cm 8.85"/22.5cm 11.41"/29cm 13.77"/35cm
Circumference (wrist): 4.52"/11.5cm 6.49"/16.5cm 8.26"/21cm 10.23"/26cm
Circumference (base): 10.23"/26cm 14.56"/37cm 18.89"/48cm 23.22"/59cm
Weight: 0.24kg (*variable) 0.24kg (*variable) 1.38kg(*variable) 2.59kg (*variable)
Price: £59 £89 £129 £159

The closed fist design is nicely detailed. From the individual fingers, knuckles, skin wrinkles and veins to the thumbnail.

It looks pretty realistic; once inside, it feels incredible. The closed Fist provides an excellent challenge when it comes to insertion, though, and it takes some patience to get it in.

JTT Fist is designed as a butt plug but can be used vaginally, too (guess how I opted to use it).

The base has the JTT logo and name shown. The broad base makes a great stop, so you do not need to worry about it slipping too far inside you. It also makes a handy way to hold the toy in use.

Image showing the flared base on the FIST butt plug
Image showing the flared base on the FIST butt plug.

This is not a vac-u-lock compatible dildo/butt plug.

JTT also provide a free faux velvet storage bag with every purchase. These bags not only look great with the black faux velvet and the white JTT branding. They also work really well. A fantastic way to keep your toy free from dust and hair while put away.

The bags are well made using a thick, strong material that is well stitched. The closure is a drawstring.


Fist is too large for me to use anally (yep, even the small), so I decided to have fun with the medium size vaginally, instructing sub 'r' to try the small anally ;-p. She did look a little pale when I gave her this instruction, but she was determined to try (good girl).

Armed with a large bottle of water-based lube, I cleared my schedule, put my do not disturb note on my door and got ready to try out the Fist.

The medium size is approximately the same as my Fist, so I knew this would be challenging. With this in mind, I knew I would need to stretch my pussy in preparation.

I started using my fingers to spread the water-based lube, ensuring I was nice and wet. Using the protruding thumb against my clit feels lovely.

Needing to stretch myself first, I had some time playing with my lovely JTT Original Dragons Cock.

As soon as I felt ready, I coated Fist with some water-based lube. Taking my time, I slowly squeezed Fist inside. It takes a bit of manoeuvring before I can finally fit the top of the Fist inside, but it is well worth the effort.

Image showing the details and textures on the FIST butt plug
Image showing the details and textures on the FIST butt plug.

The soft firmness rating provides a nice amount of squish, giving me more ease squeezing it to fit. As soon as the fingers are inside, I pause for a moment. Rubbing my clit to help relax my muscles enough to push the remainder of the Fist inside.

The feeling of stretch and fullness is fantastic. Instead of moving the Fist in and out of my pussy I enjoy simply twisting it. The sensations of expanding, feeling stretched and full, and the feeling of the Fist turning inside feels terrific. Having it run over my sensitive walls at each spin gives me fantastic sensations.

sub 'r' let me know that although she had to work on stretching her ass for quite a while, she eventually managed to get the small Fist inside. This was using a good quantity of water-based lube too.

Once inside, she thoroughly enjoyed the full feeling as it sat still. sub 'r' then played with her clit and pussy until she was coming so hard she nearly forced the entire Fist out of her ass.

Cleaning is simple; either place it in the dishwasher or use warm soapy water with anti-bacterial soap. We both found that we needed to use a soft toothbrush to ensure all the little gaps were completely clean.

Once clean, we leave ours out to air dry before placing it back inside the storage bag that JTT provide. I do not recommend using a towel, as the fluff will stick to the silicone.

Having used it on many occasions, it is a design I can highly recommend if you want to feel incredibly full with the fisting fantasy making it even more fun.

Check Out Our Review Video On Youtube

Check out my review video on Youtube

Check out Joanne's review of FIST a silicone butt plug from @JohnThomasToys. Click to Tweet

Key Features

Key features:

  • Four sizes available.
  • Four colour options.
  • Two firmness ratings.
  • Realistic closed fist design.
  • Platinum grade silicone.
  • Comes with a branded storage bag.

I would recommend it to:

  • Anyone who enjoys being fisted.
  • Anyone who wants to try fisting.
  • Anyone who wants a wide butt plug.
  • Anyone who wants a realistic fist dildo/butt plug.

I wouldn't recommend it to:

  • Anyone who wants a straight dildo/butt plug.
  • Anyone who wants a slim dildo/butt plug.

Image showing the top of the FIST butt plug
Image showing the top of the FIST butt plug.

Final Thoughts

We used FIST vaginally and anally, which was a fun challenge. I and sub 'r' have enjoyed our experience with Fist from JTT.

It is an excellent way to add a fisting fantasy into your butt plug play, and it is a nice change from regular-shaped plugs. Insertion can be a challenge, but that adds to the fun.

If you want to swap between pussy and anal play, I recommend boiling it to sanitise it. That is if you have a pot large enough :-)

FIST is a great way to introduce yourself to fisting play. Or to just enjoy having a fist plugging a hole.

I was sent these four FIST butt plugs by John Thomas Toys and I would like to thank them for giving me the opportunity to review them.

Joanne's rating

Ease of use

Where Can I Get One From?

John Thomas Toys

So, if you fancy challenging yourself then why not grab one of these marvelous butt plugs s direct from John Thomas Toys, with prices starting at just £59. At the time of this reviews publication, JTT are having a huge sale so now is really the time to grab a bargain.

Check them out and don’t forget to tell them that Joanne says "Hi".

If you enjoyed reading this review then check out my other reviews of John Thomas Toys products:


This review does not contain affiliate links, for more information about affiliate links check out my disclosure page.

Additional Info

  • Overall Rating: 9.2
Published in Butt Plugs
Joanne Summers

Sex Blogger, reviewer, dildo afficianado, kinky quimsticking, electrosex loving mum.

I've been reviewing sex toys and adult products for the last seven years and I love doing what I do. Recently I have been designing my own range of e-stim electrodes.

If you find my reviews and articles interesting please leave a comment for me on them, I love reading feedback about them. Or alternatively you could Buy Me A Coffee, wink, wink.

Leave a comment

This is to prevent spammers from touting their wares on my site. If you are a spammer, then please save both your time and mine by not bothering, as your posts will never be approved, and no one will see them anyway. They will simply be deleted.